Saturday, December 22, 2007

Lamplighting Quotations

Rubens and the Classical Tradition (I)

On December 11 we make a cultural visit to the Museo del Prado , with students of Classical Mythology course (provided by me for the Bachelor of Art History at the University of Córdoba). Our purpose was to discuss a selection of pictures of mythological themes. The visit was interesting and entertaining, I think, but tired (we did the trip back and forth on the day.) There were two problems: bureaucratic rigidity of the rules of the museum, because although we had a group entry previously agreed, with this we were not allowed access to the temporary exhibition "Velázquez's Fables" (especially interested us because included several pictures of mythological), so we had to leave the museum, get a second entry (individual) and re-enter, the second difficulty is that some of the pictures we planned to see, especially followers of Rubens (Cornelis de Vos , Jacob Jordaens), were not exposed in the permanent exhibition but stored in the warehouse. However, the visit was worthwhile.

Enough of the pictures that we were interested Peter Paul Rubens (1570-1640) or his workshop. The Prado has many paintings of Rubens' mythological theme for one simple reason. The Flemish painter in the last decade of his life when he was a respected and sought-after artist, coveted by all courts and aristocratic houses of Europe, received a major order of the English King Philip IV: decorate the walls of the Torre de la Parada (a mansion of rest, located in Monte de El Pardo, the king used for hunting) with about 120 boxes of mythological and hunting themes. Most of the mythological-themed paintings are inspired by episodes narrated by Ovid in his Metamorphoses . Do not forget that Metamorphosis of Ovid were the basic handbook of mythology for European artists, especially since the Renaissance. Well, after many ups and downs (as most of the paintings from the Torre de la Parada were lost in 1710 due to the looting of the stand by the troops of the Archduke Charles during the War of Succession), about fourteen boxes Rubens's mythological, from the series, on display at the Museo del Prado.

Rubens had received a liberal education, classical quite complete. When analyzed with students their mythological works, I like to have an impact on some details that reveal and suggest that knowledge, rather than superficial, of the classic texts. For example, Rubens tried at least two pictures the episode of Achilles' stay on the island of Skyros: "Achilles discovered by Ulysses (in collaboration with Van Dyck) and" Achilles discovered among the daughters of Licomedes "at we will refer immediately.

The story is known. The sea goddess Thetis, Achilles' mother, wanted to deliver his son to participate in the Trojan War (the first known case in the history of "conscientious objection"). For this, the disguised girl, when the child was 9, and hid (girl-like) on the island of Skyros, where there was Licomedes between Deidamia (daughter of the King) and her ladies. But the Greeks needed the participation of Achilles, as the seer Calchas had prophesied that Troy could not be conquered if Achilles was not part of the Greek contingent. So Odysseus and Diomedes, disguised as merchants, go to the island, offering clothing and trinkets, mixed with weapons Deidamia and their ladies. Then she reveals the masculine identity of Achilles, for while all the girls are interested in the ornaments, Achilles eyes will go towards weapons. This tells. Well, This episode is captured beautifully in the following table by Rubens, "Achilles discovered among the daughters of Licomedes"


The two characters who whisper to the right are Ulysses and Diomedes. Deidamia is on the left, dressed in white and surrounded by her sisters and ladies. And Achilles occupies the central position, dressed as a girl, but interested in the weapons (it is fitting a helmet on his head.) At this point, I asked the students an apparent banality: what color is the hair of Achilles and why it represents and Rubens?

The answer is: Achilles is depicted as red (interestingly, her dress also matches the color of your hair) and because it represents Rubens knew mythographic detail that when the hero remained in Skyros, disguised as a girl, took the name Pyrrha female (which means, in Greek, "the blonde" or "the redhead"). In fact, the son who would eventually have to Deidamia, which had made her pregnant when he left for the war, also called Pyrrhus (or Neoptolemus), but that's another story.

The episode of the table has, for example, in Ovid, Metamorphoses 13162-170, but that does not mention the name of Pyrrha detail. Sí lo comenta expresamente Higino, en Fábulas 96, pasaje que muy bien pudo ser la fuente mitográfica concreta de Rubens para esto. He aquí el texto latino, y un traducción:

ACHILLES

Thetis Nereis cum sciret Achillem filium suum, quem ex Peleo habebat, si ad Troiam expugnandam isset, periturum, commendavit eum in insulam Scyron ad Lycomedem regem, quem ille inter virgines filias habitu femineo servabat nomine mutato; nam virgines Pyrrham nominarunt, quoniam capillis flavis fuit et Graece rufum "pyrrhon" dicitur. Achivi autem cum rescissent ibi eum occultari, ad regem Lycomeden oratores miserunt, qui rogarent, ut eum adiutorium Danais mitteret. Rex cum negaret apud se esse, potestatem eis fecit, ut in regia quaererent. Qui cum intellegere non possent, quis esset eorum, Ulixes in regio vestibulo munera feminea posuit, in quibus clipeum et hastam, et subito tubicinem iussit canere armorumque crepitum et clamorem fieri iussit. Achilles hostem arbitrans adesse vestem muliebrem dilaniavit atque clipeum et hastam arripuit. Ex hoc est cognitus suasque operas Argivis promisit et milites Myrmidones.

AQUILES

La nereida Tetis, como supiera que su hijo Aquiles, el que tenía con Peleo, moriría si iba a luchar contra Troya, lo confió al rey Licomedes en la isla de Esciros. Éste lo alojaba entre sus hijas doncellas, cambiándole el nombre; pues las chicas lo llamaron "Pyrrha," it was fair-haired and in Greek "red" is said pyrrhon . For its part, the Achaeans, after learning that was hidden there, sent legates to the king Licomedes, asking him to hand him over to help the Achaeans. He said although he was not at home, were granted permission to record the palace. Unable to find them who was the girls Achilles, Odysseus put women's dresses in the area of \u200b\u200bthe hall, mingling among them a shield and spear, and suddenly ordered to sound the bugle and the formation of arms and crying noisily. Achilles, believing that the enemy attacked, tore her dress as a woman and grabbed the coat and lance. For this he was recognized and promised their own work to the Argives and their soldiers, the Myrmidons.

In the next post , second and last of the series, I will discuss another aspect of the knowledge of the classics of Rubens, as an example of practical application to everyday life Classical Tradition. Until then, Merry Christmas.

Friday, November 9, 2007

Indigo Online Leafeon

There is no sex life in the grave (II) Changes in the blog


I spent as a post , long ago, the topic of literature that could be labeled as "No sexual life after the grave" ("There is no sex life in the grave"), the thread of a appointment of Jaime Gil de Biedermann. See here . Then commented that he had located a text, supposedly Auden, on the subject. But given the unsubtle style of the poem, I was inclined to think that it was not for this author. A more careful investigation has produced results: Auden's poem, but in reality is an excerpt from a "antimasque" (sort of bizarre or grotesque farce) entitled The Entertainment of the Senses . Moreover, the text is put into the mouth of a monkey (yes, a monkey). Hence, perhaps, his vulgarity. Then reproduce this post a short article on the issue I posted in the journal CA News 36 (June 2007), pp. 7-8 (with the collaboration of Monica M. Martinez), in which we trace the history of the subject in classical and English poetry.

Note: CA News is the body The Classical Association (Society of British Classical Studies).


THERE IS NO SEX LIFE IN THE GRAVE :
FROM THE GREEK ANTHOLOGY
TO WH AUDEN

The carpe diem is one of The Most Celebrated and ancient tropes in Western Literature. It is an epicurean exhortation to seize the day and to enjoy love and wine as a kind of solace for the brevity of human life. This invitation becomes an instrument of seduction when the poet attempts to convince the female addressee that she should love him now, while she is still young and fresh like a rose, being her beauty as ephemeral as that of the flower. As an argument to strengthen his case, the poet may adduce then the post mortem nulla voluptas argument: there is no sex life in the grave. Statements of this kind did already occur in the Anacreontea (IV, IX, XXXVI) and in the Greek Anthology . Among the many epigrams on love and death in the latter, the following (V 85), written by the Hellenistic poet Asclepiades of Samos, is by far the most meaningful:

Φείδῃ παρθενίης. καὶ τί πλέον; οὐ γὰρ ἐς Ἅιδην
ἐλθοῦσ' εὑρήσεις τὸν φιλέοντα, κόρη.
ἐν ζωοῖσι τὰ τερπνὰ τὰ Κύπριδος· ἐν δ' Ἀχέροντι
ὀστέα καὶ σποδιή, παρθένε, κεισόμεθα.
Around 1888, Andrew Lang wrote an English version of the Greek epigram:

TO A GIRL

Believe me, love, it is not good
To hoard a mortal maidenhood;
In Hades thou wilt never find,
Maiden, a lover to thy mind;
Love’s for the living! presently
Ashes and dust in death are we.
This motif is developed in English Literature. Andrew Marvell (1621-1678) resorts to it in his famous “To his coy Mistress”, a poem included in many compilations of seventeenth-century poetry. In the first part of this poem (ll. 1-20), Marvell pictures the hypothesis that he and his lady could enjoy their love without limits of space and time: in that case there would be no need to hurry or seize the day. In the second part (ll. 21-32), Marvell envisages the corruption of the tomb, developing the post mortem nulla voluptas argument :

But at my back I alwaies hear
Times winged Charriot hurrying near:
And yonder all before us lye
Desarts of vast Eternity.
Thy Beauty shall no more be found;
Nor, in thy marble Vault, shall sound
My echoing Song: then Worms shall try
That long preserv’d Virginity:
And your quaint Honour turn to dust;
And into ashes all my Lust.
The Grave’s a fine and private place,
But none I think do there embrace.
As death is not only inevitable but joyless, the pleasures of life, specially love and sex, must be boldly seized. This is the conclusion reached by the poem’s speaker in the third part (ll. 33-46).

There are other occurrences of the post mortem nulla voluptas motif in English literature. One quite famous in contemporary poetry appears in The Entertainment of the Senses (1973), an antimasque written by W. H. Auden (1907-1973) and Chester Kallman (1921-1975). The characters of this play are five apes, who represent the five senses and speak by turns, and a CHAMBERLAIN, who introduces and closes the antimasque. All of them encourage the audience to enjoy the pleasures of the senses before the arrival of Death. The FIRST APE, who represents Touch, asserts:

When you see a fair form, chase it
And if possible embrace it,
Be it a girl or boy.
Don’t be bashful: be brash, be fresh.
Life is short, so enjoy
Whatever contact your flesh
May at the moment crave:
There’s no sex-life in the grave .
Incidentally, this passage is quoted in the film Gruppo di Famiglia in un Interno (1974), by L. Visconti. Where Marvell had Lady historical Warned of time's fleeting nature and the imminence of death, urging her to consummate Physically Their love, These contemporary poets Their audience urged to seize the day promiscuously. In Both we can see the Refusal to exchange the pleasures of the present for a dubious promise of happiness in a world to come. They Knew for sure: there is no sex life in the grave.

Gabriel Laguna Mariscal (University of Córdoba)
Mónica María Martínez-Sariego (University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria
)